I'm thankful for the things I have,
and even for the things I don't.
You find this hard to understand,
so let me tell you why and how.
I'm thankful for whate'er God gifts;
the health, the spouse, the kids and more
a million things I ask in prayers,
He might answer, He might not,
for deep in heart I have the faith
(some might not at all agree),
that only what He has to give,
and only that, is good for me.
Comments
beautiful Rula
A couple of suggestions
'for I have faith down and deep' .... is just a fraction awkward
can you think of another way to say it? - i know you don't like to use other's suggestions, so I'll leave you to think about it
Fourth verse seems a fraction long - can i suggest you drop the ' and how'?
'and million things I ask in prayers' .... make 'and' 'a'
'though some might not wholly agree' ... also seems a tad long...?drop 'wholly'
'and only that is good for me' .... put a comma after 'that'
Best of luck in the contest
love judy
xxx
thank you dear Judy
For your thoughts.
Appreciate it.
Good to read the poem apt in
Good to read the poem apt in the context of the contest theme and approaching Thanksgiving Day and also good to see you and Judy show great sporting spirit by helping each other inspite of both participating in the contest.
Best wishes to both of you.
Thank you raj
Can't I convince you to participate :(
Very sporting of you Rula to
Very sporting of you Rula to offer for me to participate. Thanks for that.
I will keep a tab on how you work on this further. Carry the winning streak of October into November.
Best of luck,
Salam, Rula
I see you put the poem's writing style as ''Structured Western''. I thought it is more to free verse..Anyway this is a good write and I wish you the best for the contest.
Alid
Oops
I thought it IS structured.
Thanks for the visit and the comment.
Rula
I like the poem. Like Judy I thought if read awkward in a couple places. Line 4 may read better ad ''so let me explain how''. Since I'm training my brain in grammar and syntax, line 5 seems it should be ''God's gifts''. And
And line 8 read awkward. Hope you the best in the contest. I'm not the best at poetry critique. So if I'm off press on to greatness.
thank you barb.
I am unhappy with that line either.
I'll leave it for a while then see what edits needed.
Thank you.
if you'd like my opinion Rula
I would delete verses 3 anf 4 totally
verse 5 reads smoothly from verse 2
and I don't think your narrator needs to explain anything
xxx
I understand dear
but you know this feeling when you like some lines (though they might sound rubbish) lol
I tried to keep all in tetrameter. Hope it's working.
STILL I like your suggestion. I might reconsider. You never know. )
Thank you
Rula
A simple thanks to those things that sustain you and make you love them always, a great write,
Yours Ian. x
thank you Ian
I missed your active presence .
Welcome back.
Hi Rula
We All have things to be thankful for don't we?..........stan