apologies Richard but the intention was not to be vague but to cite an example...
..............................................................................................................................
I think raj's point is very valid and complaints against irrelevant or perhaps inappropriate or even abusive comments should somehow allow to easily have their points removed.
I do appreciate that there is always a flip side / exception. My bringing this possibility to notice is not with an intent to question the merits of qualification norm for The Lab or put pressure on the administrators by making their work unduly laborious...if Andrew and his team do not find an easy way out to tackle such situations we will take them in our stride and move on...ultimately we need to look at the bigger picture and ignore such aberrations.. hope this clarifies my intent...
.............................................
I agree, we just can't have people
dismissing points because they don't
agree with an assessment of their poem,
even when we may disagree with the
tone ...
Because of situations like these, I believe
we will need to settle disputes with AC,
whoever they may be at the time. Depending
on how often there are complaints, we may
even need a special complaint block that
will ensure a quicker response.
looks like nothing much is being reported about this plan since July 2018...hopefully not aborted..
.................................................................
and this has been said but needs to
be underlined ... this still depends on
member participation, you all should be
giving each other thorough critiques now,
or attempting to.
the lab effort? Not really sure what
that means but yes, the lab will continue
to evolve and may require new and improved
rules to keep some order ... did you have
specific details in mind?
Rules are because of the less than
honorable among us, so yes, there
will be some. It goes without saying
that in the lab critique is the center
but I think if a member doesn't participate,
they should be bounced back to stream,
this hasn't been presented as of yet .
apologies Richard but the
apologies Richard but the intention was not to be vague but to cite an example...
..............................................................................................................................
Without naming names
I think raj's point is very valid and complaints against irrelevant or perhaps inappropriate or even abusive comments should somehow allow to easily have their points removed.
Hi Mark
I do appreciate that there is always a flip side / exception. My bringing this possibility to notice is not with an intent to question the merits of qualification norm for The Lab or put pressure on the administrators by making their work unduly laborious...if Andrew and his team do not find an easy way out to tackle such situations we will take them in our stride and move on...ultimately we need to look at the bigger picture and ignore such aberrations.. hope this clarifies my intent...
.............................................
Ok guys,
I agree, we just can't have people
dismissing points because they don't
agree with an assessment of their poem,
even when we may disagree with the
tone ...
Because of situations like these, I believe
we will need to settle disputes with AC,
whoever they may be at the time. Depending
on how often there are complaints, we may
even need a special complaint block that
will ensure a quicker response.
peeping in here
to see if there is any information / development/update about The Lab
......................................................................
looks like nothing much is
looks like nothing much is being reported about this plan since July 2018...hopefully not aborted..
.................................................................
Hi folks,
This project has not been abandoned,
we are only a few so please be patient.
Let me add ...
and this has been said but needs to
be underlined ... this still depends on
member participation, you all should be
giving each other thorough critiques now,
or attempting to.
Undermining
the lab effort? Not really sure what
that means but yes, the lab will continue
to evolve and may require new and improved
rules to keep some order ... did you have
specific details in mind?
Well Mark,
Rules are because of the less than
honorable among us, so yes, there
will be some. It goes without saying
that in the lab critique is the center
but I think if a member doesn't participate,
they should be bounced back to stream,
this hasn't been presented as of yet .